QUOTE (Ieshwar @ June 18 2007, 03:30 AM)

A Special Chemistry by YaalcA very unusual love story. You efficiently described the feelings of the Trevor and Marc at each step. But what I greatly appreciated was the conversation of Trevor with his mum. You made me realize that what we hear and see isn’t always the real thing; had Trevor not asked that simple question he would have perhaps never known about his mother’s opinions. Great story!

I agree. We all have a tendency to read more into things than is often really there. A simple question to get clarification can often make a big difference.
Oh, and I'm putting up my hand for one of those little pink pills.

QUOTE (Ieshwar @ June 18 2007, 03:30 AM)

Father’s day by GraemeI noticed the definite contrast between Ryan’s father and Adam’s father (was it intended?). If the first one is a plain jerk (I completely agree with Ryan), the second one is a father who has well fulfilled his role. Graeme has very well portrayed Ryan- the hate for his father, immense love for his mum and somewhere, the frustration inside him. If I hadn’t known Graeme better, I would have thought that he was an angsty teen, who is aware the pain of a fatherless child. Hats off!

Thank you! It is also a complete coincidence that it was posted on Father's Day (at least for some countries).
Yes, the contrast was deliberate. What I was trying to show was that even though Ryan didn't have a father in his life, he still had good male role-models around. I was very conscious while writing this story that there are strong parallels with the challenges in front of single parent families and the arguments used to try to prohibit same-sex couple adopting, or having access to IVF. Many single parent families prove the lie about children requiring both a mother and a father -- and it is often because they take advantage of an extended "family" to help bring up their children.
QUOTE (Ieshwar @ June 18 2007, 03:30 AM)

The Shining Light by NickIt’s rare to read a story from the POV of a ten-year old boy. Nevertheless, it was damn effective. I couldn’t help but compare it with ‘Father’s Day’. If Ryan had spent years without his father and has kinda accepted the idea, James is still young and pines for his father. I really liked his recollections about his father but what I loved was the last line. “…so that the light would shine in from the hallway.” It told so many things and also the reason for the title! Great!

My eldest boy is eight, and I can see the start of James's thinking in him. Nick has picked the thoughts, attention span, and the priorities of a ten-year-old extremely well. Well done!

QUOTE (Ieshwar @ June 18 2007, 03:30 AM)

P.S I would like to disgree with Nick! I don't think there're just two great writers; I find three.

especially after reading these three stories.
I only counted two -- Nick and Yaalc...

Seriously, though, I agree -- Nick is a great writer and I think he'll get even better with time. He's already showing his versatility with the range of characters he writes about.