Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: DomLuka IS Jane Austen
Gay Authors > Story Discussions > Hosted Authors > Domaholics
corvus
It doesn't have quite the catch of 'Callas IS Carmen,' but it's true. Here's why:

*spoilers*

- Both Jane and Dom focus on one specific spatial setting. Pride and Prejudice (P&P) and Sense and Sensibility (S&S) took place in the English country gentry, with brief excursions into town. Log Way took place in one neighborhood; DD around another. This is more important than it seems -- I believe it's an authorial choice, or instinct.
- Both Jane and Dom focus on a specific social stratus. Jane on the country gentry; Dom on the working middle class.
- Romance is important but subsidiary. Jane's characters focus on securing their financial situation; Dom on coming of age and coming to terms with oneself and one's family. This makes the romantic aspect more believable and avoids running the risk of being maudlin.
- Jane and Dom have a wicked sense of humor.
- DD and P&P have very similar plots. Elizabeth/Rory initially fancies Wickham/Aaron and dislikes Darcy/Seth. Then, over the course of a delicious courtship, Elizabeth/Rory units with Darcy/Seth.
- Both have writing styles that are direct and straightforward.

*end spoilers*

Hmm, my arguments seemed better when they were still in my head. And they consider only a small part of each author's ouvre. But, well, here's another:

- I reread both of them like mad.

biggrin.gif I am such a Domaholic. He should come back before I start comparing him to Tolstoy... blink.gif
darkfoxprime
QUOTE (corvus @ March 4 2008, 02:11 PM) *
biggrin.gif I am such a Domaholic. He should come back before I start comparing him to Tolstoy... blink.gif


Oh no, does that mean we can look forward to War and Trust? biggrin.gif

I miss Dom. I hope he's surviving and thriving at whatever he's doing, of course, but I also hope he'll make it back here soon. smile.gif

- dfp
Ieshwar
QUOTE (corvus @ March 5 2008, 02:11 AM) *
biggrin.gif I am such a Domaholic. He should come back before I start comparing him to Tolstoy... blink.gif


Oh, do inform me when you reach J.K Rowling!! biggrin.gif

Ieshwar
Hylas
huh.gif

He's not!

He's Ayn Rand!
Menzoberranzen
QUOTE (Hylas @ March 5 2008, 05:15 AM) *
huh.gif

He's not!

He's Ayn Rand!


I <3 Ayn Rand and I <3 Dom, but I don't see the resemblence.
AFriendlyFace
QUOTE (corvus @ March 4 2008, 05:11 PM) *
It doesn't have quite the catch of 'Callas IS Carmen,' but it's true. Here's why:

*spoilers*

- Both Jane and Dom focus on one specific spatial setting. Pride and Prejudice (P&P) and Sense and Sensibility (S&S) took place in the English country gentry, with brief excursions into town. Log Way took place in one neighborhood; DD around another. This is more important than it seems -- I believe it's an authorial choice, or instinct.
- Both Jane and Dom focus on a specific social stratus. Jane on the country gentry; Dom on the working middle class.
- Romance is important but subsidiary. Jane's characters focus on securing their financial situation; Dom on coming of age and coming to terms with oneself and one's family. This makes the romantic aspect more believable and avoids running the risk of being maudlin.
- Jane and Dom have a wicked sense of humor.
- DD and P&P have very similar plots. Elizabeth/Rory initially fancies Wickham/Aaron and dislikes Darcy/Seth. Then, over the course of a delicious courtship, Elizabeth/Rory units with Darcy/Seth.
- Both have writing styles that are direct and straightforward.

*end spoilers*

Hmm, my arguments seemed better when they were still in my head. And they consider only a small part of each author's ouvre. But, well, here's another:

- I reread both of them like mad.

biggrin.gif I am such a Domaholic. He should come back before I start comparing him to Tolstoy... blink.gif


This is fantastic, Corvus!!! thumbsupsmileyanim.gif specool.gif lmaosmiley.gif
QUOTE (darkfoxprime @ March 4 2008, 05:20 PM) *
Oh no, does that mean we can look forward to War and Trust? biggrin.gif

laugh.gif

I can already see this entering the next round of Dom Trivia

"Dom has been compared to which classic author?"
Krista
Oh I love Jane Austen. wub.gif wub.gif My goodness I've read her.. a billion times over the years.. and I could read her another billion if I can find the time to.. lol. I've also found myself rereading Dom as well. The comparisons can be made I guess, both exceptional writers in their own right.

smile.gif
Rose Strailo
I love Jane Austen. I grew up on her. Though, I must say, Dom is kinda like her, like you say. *thinks about it* Shocking, that this thread made sense to me. blink.gif
BeaStKid
*Comes to this thread excitedly, hoping for some news about Dom. Goes back to his posting after realizing its just another plea*


SIGH!

BeaStKid
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.