QUOTE (Cynical Romantic @ July 30 2008, 12:22 AM)

Okay, I guess I should explain what I meant when I said that I thought Aaron was wrong.
See, I think Aaron believes that he is "in love with Ben" and merely "loves Mick". I think he has all the rationalization and all the logic worked out in his mind, exactly as you wrote it. And, given what you have told us about him, I totally get why he believes that. It's very easy to confuse lust and love, especially the first few times around.
Yes, that's exactly what I think is going on here. Aaron is in lust with Ben. Not in love with him. Hell, he hardly even knows him. There's obviously a physical attraction. There's obviously a "rush", a sense of "adventure" as Aaron puts it. There's not a small amount of confusion due to simple horomones, too. After all, Aaron and Ben have done some heavy-duty making out (love that "shortstop" metaphor) but Aaron and Mick haven't crossed any lines, so that's probably clouding Aaron's judgment, too. Besides, I think Aaron has been flattered all along by Ben's attention, in a "what could a guy like that see in a guy like me?" kind of way. Not that Ben is better than Aaron, just that Aaron's insecurities may be leading him to believe that.
But love... Aaron is confusing the butterflies with the real thing. What he has with Mick - the comfort, the security, the trust... the physical attraction, yes, but mostly the sense that Mick is "home"... that's love. I just don't think Aaron has the capacity to understand that just yet, even despite all the psych courses he's taken. He hasn't experienced enough yet to know it.
Now, I don't know whether Mick loves Aaron. You haven't given us enough to go on, even despite Ben's suspicions and Jake's near-certainty. We haven't seen it from Mick, and really, what other people think doesn't matter. Maybe Mick is really in love with Aaron. Maybe he's not. If he is, I suspect he might be either unsure of his sexuality and therefore unsure whether he can be what Aaron needs, or maybe he knows that Aaron is nowhere near ready to love him back yet. Maybe he's encouraging Aaron to go out and have his fun with guys like Ben, so he can learn a few lessons about lust versus love, and he'll be more ready to love him then. (If that's the case, I'd like to hit Mick over the head with a 2x4, because all that nonsense about "if you love someone, set them free", etc. is just that... nonsense. Timing is everything, and if you let your chance slip away, you could live with a lifetime of regret when someone else gets there first. But I digress...) Anyway, whatever Mick's motivations are, I guess they'll be clearer in the sequel, but I'm more talking about what Aaron is going through.
I want to be
really careful what I say to avoid giving out spoilers, but I have to say I think this is an extremely well thought-out analysis! As the author
I don't want to confirm or discredit it, but I'm dying to hear what other readers think about it!
QUOTE (Cynical Romantic @ July 30 2008, 12:22 AM)

Ever see the movie "Almost Famous" where Philip Seymour Hoffman's character is talking about how most of the great art in the world is about "love disguised as sex, and sex disguised as love"? I think that's an apt description of what's going on here.
Thanks for the movie recommendation! I'm actually having a movie night with some friends Saturday. I'll recommend this one! I think that's an extremely astute evaluation in general my lips are sealed about how it ties into BMAD/WAS though

QUOTE (Cynical Romantic @ July 30 2008, 12:22 AM)

And hey, we've all been there at least once. Aaron's in good company.
Very true!
QUOTE (Cynical Romantic @ July 30 2008, 12:22 AM)

I don't know whether this is what you had in mind. Maybe you believe the opposite, and hey, you're the author, so you pretty much get to write it as you see it. But if you're gonna write such lifelike characters, you can't blame 'em for taking on a life of their own, and maybe heading in directions that even you didn't intend, right?
Looking forward to the sequel!

Thanks, Cyn! I really appreciate it! I hope you enjoy the sequel as well!
QUOTE (wildone @ July 30 2008, 05:59 PM)

Kev,
Thank you very much for sharing this story with us

, as I think I said earlier, it is one story that I was checking daily for new chapters, and there are few stories that I do that. I will be waiting eagerly for WAS to come out to see where this goes to.
Wow! Thanks Steve! I'm really flattered!
QUOTE (wildone @ July 30 2008, 05:59 PM)

I am actually glad that you took the time in the forums to tell us that this story was more or less a prologue for WAS. I do believe that if someone was reading it without having any knowledge of continuation, they may feel let down.
Let me explain that, hopefully before you take that the wrong way....negatively.
The one thing that worked in BMAD as a prologue which I don't personally believe would work in a stand alone story would be the character development. Off the start we all saw what type of person Aaron was, and didn't have too much development of other characters like Mick and Jake until the end of the story. We were also introduced to Ronnie (who played a major role in one chapter), and also early on we were introduced to Ben and his circle of friends. When Aaron first started talking with Ben, and considered he was falling for Ben, we learned more about Ben and those friends. Unfortunately any development of those friends characters were noticeably stopped, and Ben was the sole focus, then moved onto Jake and Mick.
We now have about nine characters that seem to be important to the development of the story but only about 3 have what I consider their 'due' in development.
I'm really glad you commented on this!
My personal impression of character development thus far is indeed that it's focused on Aaron, Ben, and Mick. However, I also feel like we've got a decent handle - or at least the beginning of one - on Ronnie (who, IMO, played a major role in chapter 3:
Makeover Madness as well as Chapter 9:
I Can't Even Think Straight ).
It's my opinion that Ronnie, Jake, and Cosmo have had a fairly influential hand in the events thus far. I agree that Jake is one of the more fleshed out characters so far, but I feel like we're starting to see decent development with Cosmo as well (though probably not to quite the same extent as Jake and Ronnie).
I will admit that Amanda, Daisy, and Giorgio are the most mysterious characters as this point!
As I see the story, Aaron is the 'main character'. This is more about him than it is about Ben, Mick, or anyone else. Ben and Mick would definitely be on the next tier and in many ways they're really only a couple of notches down from Aaron.
Cosmo, Ronnie, and Jake are the three most important 'supporting characters'. I expect to have them really well developed by the end of the story (the final end that is).
Daisy, and Giorgio would slip in after them and I expect them to get a very fair and thorough due as well.
Amanda creeps in just behind them. I'm not completely sure where she'll take me at this point. I confess that thus far in the story, and thus far in what I've written of WAS, her primary function has been in terms of how she relates to Jake and Ronnie (who as I said I would consider two of my most important 'non-starring' characters if you will).
So you're right, Steve: I have nine characters so far that have an important role in the development of the story.
I will say that my opinion and analysis so far is based on BMAD, what I've written of WAS, and the outline I have. There will definitely be other characters in the sequel who may or may not be enduring, and these characters, as well as the ones mentioned above, are certainly 'subject to change' in terms of their importance and focus. I'm not going to be rigid and refuse to let the story take me where it feels appropriate.
QUOTE (wildone @ July 30 2008, 05:59 PM)

I kept this in mind the entire time that I was reading BMAD and kept reminding myself that more would come in the next story.
Hopefully this is true

Well, you mentioned that you thought Aaron, Ben, Mick and Jake had had a lot 'screen time'

, I'll say this the first few chapters of WAS focus a good bit of attention on the development of another character.
Anyway, I'm a very character oriented writer, so I certainly hope I am able to give all nine (and
maybe more

) their fair due.
QUOTE (wildone @ July 30 2008, 05:59 PM)

I always thought that Aaron actually over analyzed things. Unfortunately all he really looked at was others. I believe that Aaron grew in the sense that he began to look in the mirror, which is much harder to do, and began analyzing himself rather than staying in his comfort zone and looking at others. I found the notebook at the bar, the school projects, etc. showed he was very observant of others, but was in the dark or afraid to do so for himself. The way he just accepted Mick and his generosity and friendship would be the most major point.
I think that's definitely a very sensible and accurate analysis as well!
Thanks Steve, I hope you enjoy the sequel as well!

-Kevin