QUOTE (Benji @ July 2 2008, 03:05 PM)

"Should I stay or should I go".
Thanks for the comments, Benji.

Is that from Les Mis, Marius's part in "One More Day"? I'm sure more than one songwriter has used it, but Les Mis popped into my mind first. It's the fault of a couple of my high school friends... they were obsessed with that musical.
QUOTE (shadowgod @ July 7 2008, 10:47 AM)

As a writer I dread these types of stories and that be my own short comings, but I plain out invest too much time into the people I create, often forming vague-to-detailed images of their lives 20 or 30 years down the line and way after the segment of their life I am writing has passed.
That said, I don't know which of these lives is more tragic. Foster seems to have a very supportive family with maybe an overbearing but clearly proud mother. Yet he seems aloof to the fact for most of the tale.
Danke schön, Steve.

I'm somewhat fond of this type of story, actually, because I'm such a lazy person I just let bits of their past come to my head instead of planning their lives out beforehand. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.
I'm actually very optimistic for both Foster and Bud. There's definitely going to be more difficulties in the future, but I believe that, overall, things are looking up for them. Of course, that could just be my imagination. B)
QUOTE (old bob @ July 7 2008, 04:18 PM)

After a second reading, everything became clear for me. The way you write is the best way to express sorrow and disillusion. The slowness, the dryness is a choice. if I imagine the scenes of your characters, it is as if I would see a film in a slackened tempo. I dont share the feelings of your characters, but I admire the way you brought it in your style.
And it is a really "short story", with a beginning and an end, but an end in a "no man's land", with no hope and no future.
I dont agree with a former opinion about a "glimpse". The story is a whole story. You have, during your reading, to ad a lot from your own. This story gave me a lot to think, about life, youth and faith. I'm sorry for the characters.
I think you have an intrinsic understanding of this story, old bob. Thanks for much for your comments.

And I think the difficulties of the first reading might be due in part to the many typos and mistakes I made...
QUOTE (rec @ July 7 2008, 06:10 PM)

Let me say at the outset that I enjoyed your excellent story. It was well written, reasonably well edited (with only a few things falling through the cracks), and the characters were nicely drawn and perfect for a short story.
However, I found that either there should have been two short stories or that they should have been more artistically bound together--with more parallelism. There were two stories of the young men that seemed primarily linked by their connection at Harvard. I never felt that I was getting two views or perspectives on the same family events and relationships. I felt the story went from one well-written theme to another.
I'm glad you thought so highly of my story, although I will protest that it wasn't well edited at all -- I was quite impatient and didn't get it betaed before I posted. Hopefully I will get off my lazy arse and do that within the next few ___.
Re: your criticism, I agree that there isn't a binding element between the two storylines, and I agree that including such an element would make an excellent story. Such an element would need to be rather subtle -- the last thing I want to do is distract the reader and get him/her all excited about some sort of "connecting symbolism." It should be subliminal. My instinct while writing this story was that, unless I could think of something suitably unobstrusive to connect the storylines, the piece as a whole wouldn't profit. Since I couldn't think of anything, I didn't write it in. (If you think of something, let me know!)
Thanks for the comments.