Jump to content

Welcome to Gay Authors

Confused? Check out one of our guides to using Gay Authors. I am here to ... Read  Write  Socialize  eBooks

If you need assistance, click  Contact Us  on the bottom of all the pages. You can remove this help box by  Signing In  or  Creating An Account  for free today!

- - - - -

Pull Quotes From Rejection Letters?

This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
4 replies to this topic



    Cool Member

  • Author: Author
  • 150 posts

Posted 15 August 2012 - 11:44 AM

Here's a general question:

I have several novels which, over the years, have been rejected by agents. Of late, instead of the old form rejections, I have been getting comments such as 'Great dialogue, great storytelling - but we don't think this will be an easy commercial sale.' (similar comments, but all saying roughly the same.)

Now, I am about to start looking at doing the self-publishing route - setting up a PoD and ebook press (I used to do semi-pro and small press publishing back when it was still a hands-dirty business) - and rather than let the postential pass by, I was wondering if I couldn't use those pull quotes to my advantage?

They are in letters addressed to me specifically - rather than some general release - and as such I feel that as I have the originals I can take a verbatim quote from some in order to help advertise the finished product.

Does anyone know differently? Is there some rule/law which forbids me from doing so?



    Gay Dad

  • Mod:  Forum Moderation Team
  • 11,873 posts

Posted 15 August 2012 - 06:00 PM

That's an interesting question, but I don't know the answer. The answer may also differ from country to country, as we don't have universal copyright laws. I'm assuming it will be a copyright issue - the person who sent you the letter owns the copyright, but I don't know what rights they've given up by sending the letter to you....

There are three types of people in the world - those that understand binary and those that don't.

Now starting to post: Leopard Spots, the sequel to Leopard Skin Cover


John Doe

    Forum Fiend

  • Author: Author
  • 495 posts

Posted 17 August 2012 - 09:20 PM

Regardless of the responses you get here, it'd be best if you get an opinion of an attorney, a currently licensed one that is. This goes into the realm of legal advise and most of us can't give legal advise. We can only speculate.
John Doe



    Apocalypse Soon ...

  • Members
  • 2,257 posts

Posted 23 August 2012 - 03:56 PM

"Business letters can be protected by copyright and forwarding them to others can be an infringement, the High Court has ruled. The decision could have implications for email communication because the same principles will apply."

The case mentioned concerned use of an entire business letter and you only want to quote extracts but the principle still holds.

However you need to consider a few points:
1. quote but don't attribute - if ever challenged [not gonna happen!] you've got the letters as proof
2. if you want to attribute why not just ask the letter writer(s) for permission to quote extracts?
3. if you don't would they realistically take action - they would have to show financial loss that made the costs and risks of litigation worthwhile
4. are their comments worth quoting e.g. would I - a potential reader - really become motivated to buy a book just because someone has said "Great dialogue, great storytelling" or would I assume those qualities and be looking for some USP about the book, you know "this is an edge of the seat roller-coaster ride from page 1" type stuff
5. could you get others to give you a friendly review that you could then quote unattributed?
Hope this helps

What's cute, blue and... innocent?  :unsure2: :funny:



    Cool Member

  • Author: Author
  • 150 posts

Posted 24 August 2012 - 12:08 PM

It helps a lot.

I suspect I could write around saying I intend to use the following pulls from letters, and should there be any objection then notify me by <date> otherwise I'll assume conscent.

Apart from the fact I get a little tee-d off with comments like 'Absolutely Fabulous, darling - but not commercial enough in the UK at the mo!' (the one from one agent actually reads like she's breaking up with me after a long relationship - it's an email I'll always treasure, and take with me to my grave :) ) the use of quotes also gives me the possibility of text balancing on the likes of covers, etc, where the title and byline fail to give the cover the correct image weight.

Of course, there is also an element of flipping the bird, a la Stephen Leather...