Jump to content
  • entries
    38
  • comments
    116
  • views
    21,697

Criminalization of Homosexuality in India: All that is black is not coal!


asamvav111

843 views

Ok, I have stayed silent for long... for too long it seems. There has been a good number of blog posts in GA and thankfully all of them are in favour of the LGBT community of India. This was expected. GA is a safe space and a close community of great solidarity. In today's hateful cyberspace, this is a truly unique oasis of love. I am really thankful for GA. But, regarding this matter, there has been some amount of confusion and misinformation as well. I want to target those and clear the air a bit.

 

First of all, homosexuality is not criminalised in India. It never was. It never will be. All citizens of India are provided equal rights and protection under the constitution. There is however a law introduced by the British that talks about the legal ramifications of the so called "unnatural sexual offenses". IPC s377 is concerned with sexual intercourse which implies penile penetration (except in the case of lesbianism where there is no penetration obviously and hence the act is termed "bodily congress") in routes other than the vaginal. This is applicable for anal and oral intercourse in both homosexual and heterosexual situations. There is no mention of sexual orientation in the law. However, it is clearly understandable that this law can easily be used to incriminate people of queer identity. The same section talks about bestiality. The punishments are of various degrees from life imprisonment to 10 years in prison to 3 years in prison with or without fine. And you need medical evidence to prove the offense (as unfortunate as as this is, I, as a Doctor, was trained in this). But, most importantly although rarely used, this is the one and only law that protects male rape victims. If this section is simply writ down without amendment or insertion of another law for the matter, there will be no law against male rape in IPC. Generally the misinformed police of India use these laws as threats to extort money from queer couples in public. This and the law against public indecency are a perpetual nightmare for couples of any orientation and a regular fund raiser for the Indian police force. It is not like they get to enjoy the bribe. the money is fed into the political system and everyone gets a share. This is an open secret in the subcontinent.

 

Secondly, although it was majorly the religious-right-wing-extremists who were the plaintiff in SC and the defendant of the Delhi High Court ruling, their focus of contention were not religion based. Such religion based contention would have fallen face first in Indian court where the concept of secularity must rule supreme, as per the constitution. Although, there is also a matter of religious freedom, it would not have worked here. The main discussion was thus focused on public health, specifically HIV/AIDS spread due to widespread sexual immorality if s377 is writ down. In Delhi High Court that was overruled due to lack of evidence and presence of evidence of the contrary. WHO provided some significant statistics in this matter. Details of the ruling are available on public domain if you wanna read the long pdf. http://judis.nic.in/supremecourt/imgs1.aspx?filename=41070

 

Lastly, SC did not overrule Delhi High Court's ruling in order to define sexual morality and to uphold an unused outdated law. They only defined the power of a lower court to suggest for such writ down. And passed the ball to parliament to do the honours. Now if only the parliament passes the bill in its current session, this law can be writ down. In any case, a clear 2/3 rd majority in upper house is needed to effect the writ down.

 

Now, these are all technical facts. Let's see what is actually happening. The current coalition in power is somewhat similar to liberal socialists of the USA. Their main vote banks are the minorities, the Scheduled Caste, the Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes. A significant proportion of these are composed of Muslims and Christians and Sikhs. So, they will not do anything to anger the religious leaders of these sects. And the religious right wing nationalist coalition, who is a strong opponent to the said coalition, is tight with these people. After all, in India the masses sway to religious fervor. They will put their vote where these leaders ask them to. This is because the general lack of education and unthinkable poverty makes them more vulnerable to God's people's council (yes just like in the middle ages). Although the current government has done much for the poor and the less fortunate, the staggering population makes it impossible to reach all. There is still much to be done. Unless the level of education is increased beyond a certain benchmark, social issues like homosexuality will never be properly understood by the masses. After all, if you are concerned about how to feed your son and daughter the next day, you can hardly be interested in what the upperclassmen of the metropolis are talking about in their comfortable drawing rooms. Still this is an issue that needs to be addressed, because globalization has hit India hard and these issues need to be discussed if India is to step into the new millennium.

 

India is a country of apparent contradictions. It is hard to understand things in a linear view. People in general are not completely against homosexuality; Especially in the metro cities, they are quite supportive. Homosexuality in men are more accepted than in women. Honour killings and rapes of LGBT are still a regular thing albeit under-reported. And the status of security of women are in all time low. But, that doesn't mean women are suppressed. For an upper-middle-class educated Bengali household my family is extremely supportive of my choices. I have seen the same with a number of other families. Then, there are those who appear liberal superficially but are deeply bigoted in heart. My religious Muslim friends are okay with my choices even if they are not okay with homosexuality. They see it as a personal choice and leave it there. Yet some of my Hindu associates find homosexuality abhorring and are all too vocal of their disgust, sometimes beyond the border of civility. This is weird since Hinduism has no moral code against Homosexuality while Islam does. Also there is a strong connection between history of childhood sexual abuse and homosexuality in the popular psyche.

 

s377 is making rounds in the media circus at the moment. The Central government (federal gov) has come out in support of the writ down. And so has a good number of politicians and ministers. However, with elections next year it is highly unlikely that a bill will be passed. Then again, Indian politics is big on minority games and if LGBT are solidified into a minority and a significant vote bank, then things will start changing really fast. Everybody wants the pink vote. Ultimately next year when the other coalition comes to power (as they most expectedly will, since the current rulers have sent the economy to dumps and the other party is considerably better at managing the economy), the prosecution of the LGBT will reach record high. Homosexuality is after all the result of western influence in Indian society, as per these bigots, therefore most ardently to be battled and the society to be purified back to its ancient glory. Trial by fire...

 

 

The best you can do for us now is, pray and wish us luck.

  • Like 7

5 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • Site Administrator

Thank you for your thoughtful insight Asam. With signing the petition I know it is a small thing but hopefully everything works out to the best in the end. I too will keep you and India in mind.

  • Like 3
Link to comment

Thanks for giving us a better understanding of what has happened in your country :)

In an earlier blog I looked at this in terms of problems inherent with "democracy" if the majority will is allowed to prevail and thereby oppress minorities. Maybe this won't happen in India - in fact it mustn't be allowed to because "the will of the majority" is toxic and cannot exist in a diverse, modern pluralistic society. Which, sadly, India is not and cannot be until the huge changes required have happened - specifically around education, poverty and the removal of institutional corruption you referred to. And the removal of all discrimination including caste-based discrimination. But that's not going to happen any time soon.

Every country, it seems, has to go through its own painful struggles and traumas. There is no shortcut and what emerges is ultimately what the people of that country want and are prepared to fight for. In the meantime you know you have our love and support here at GA :)
 

  • Like 2
Link to comment

Thanks Fishyy, Wild One. You did a splendid job with the petition. I'm sure things like that will bring us results.

Thanks for giving us a better understanding of what has happened in your country :)

In an earlier blog I looked at this in terms of problems inherent with "democracy" if the majority will is allowed to prevail and thereby oppress minorities. Maybe this won't happen in India - in fact it mustn't be allowed to because "the will of the majority" is toxic and cannot exist in a diverse, modern pluralistic society. Which, sadly, India is not and cannot be until the huge changes required have happened - specifically around education, poverty and the removal of institutional corruption you referred to. And the removal of all discrimination including caste-based discrimination. But that's not going to happen any time soon.

Every country, it seems, has to go through its own painful struggles and traumas. There is no shortcut and what emerges is ultimately what the people of that country want and are prepared to fight for. In the meantime you know you have our love and support here at GA :)
 

Thank you for your input Zombie! What you say is true. However, by the law India is indeed a modern pluralistic democratic society and perhaps the biggest example of the fact that legislation can not change the popular mindset. As I mentioned in the blog, being a minority is a big thing in India. Government Quotas will open doors to places you otherwise can't imagine and the representation is good too. But, this has done little to disperse the stigma associated with thousands years old discrimination. There is still hope. Globalization has done much to bring forth a new dimension of ideals to modern Indian youth. And even if there are a few black sheep, things are changing for the better. Caste based discrimination are no longer a majority ideal. Even 20 years back inter-caste marriages were frowned upon. Now-a-days, parents are happy if their son marries a girl not a boy, caste be damned. Caste based discrimination has given way to religion based discrimination. May be one day that will pass too.  In the meanwhile, we must fight.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

Thanks for posting this.  It clarified much about the law in theory and practice in India.  Best wishes for continued progress in civil rights and change for the better.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Our Privacy Policy can be found here: Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue..